Jasbir discovered the body of her father, Sukhbinder Singh, whose photo is held by her mother
Punjab suicides cast shadow on polls
Punjab suicides cast shadow on polls
By Suvojit Bagchi BBC News, Barnala, Punjab
Mandip Kaur, a 29-year-old housewife from a farming family in southern Punjab, guards her husband round the clock.
"I fear he may commit suicide," she says in broken Hindi.
Almost every village in Punjab has witnessed a suicide in their once-prosperous farming families and it is a major issue in the general election.
Ms Kaur's 35-year-old husband, Lakhbir Singh, a small farmer with a two-acre land holding, is a strong and neatly dressed man.
He shows no sign of irritation or discomfort when we meet him in the village of Boparai Khurd in Barnala, about 500km (300 miles) north of Delhi.
Each year before the harvest, the small farmers of Punjab, who make up nearly 85% of the state's farming community, borrow from local rural moneylenders at exorbitant interest rates to meet production costs, including fertilisers and electricity for irrigation.
“ Commodity prices are plummeting in the international market... and farmer suicides may increase in coming months ”
"[Lakhbir] has a loan of more than 700,000 rupees ($15,000), which he cannot repay," says Ms Kaur.
Defaulting on payment increases the rates of interest and a farmer is publicly humiliated in the local panchayat (self-governing rural body) if he fails to pay up.
"His elder brother, my father, committed suicide more than a year ago, as his loan had accumulated up to $20,000," says 15-year-old Jasbir, who discovered her father's body.
"I do not think I can ever repay the whole amount," Lakhbir confesses.
The Bhartiya Kisan Union-Ekta, (BKU-United), one of the largest farmers' unions in Punjab, is urging its members not to vote in the election if they feel that none of the parties is addressing their needs.
'Major issue'
National Crime Records Bureau statistics say close to 200,000 farmers have committed suicide in India since 1997.
The Punjab government says the state produces nearly two-thirds of the grain in India.
But the state has faced many economic crises since the the mid-1990s.
No comprehensive official figures on farmer suicides in the area are available.
But a report commissioned by the government of Punjab this week estimated that there had been "close to 3,000 suicides" among farmers and farm labourers in just two of Punjab's 20 districts in recent years, agriculture ministry sources told the BBC.
The general secretary of BKU-United, Sukhdev Singh Khokri, says: "The findings of this report will snowball into a major electoral issue."
Another government report published in 2007 suggested that "about 12% of marginal and small farmers have left farming" over the past few years.
Among the reasons is the lack of access to credit, a facility denied by banks to farmers with no property.
"Bank loans to small farmers without collateral declined sharply as India introduced neo-liberal policies in the 1990s," says Bernard D'Mello, deputy editor of Economic and Political Weekly.
Farmers had to approach rural moneylenders who charge exorbitant rates.
Amarjit Singh, another small farmer from Barnala whose father committed suicide a few years back, says: "My father could not read or write, so he could not calculate the amount of loan he had incurred.
"Once it reached a staggering sum, he was publicly threatened by the moneylender and committed suicide.
"If I am asked to pay my father's debt, I will also have to commit suicide," says Amarjit, who has also taken on loans to meet rising production costs.
Surplus
The Punjab government's website proclaims that "India has gone from a food-deficit to a food-surplus country" largely because of the Green Revolution of Punjab.
In the 1960s, it revolutionised agricultural production by introducing high-yield varieties of seeds, chemical fertilisers, insecticides and machinery.
But the 2007 report criticises the revolution and its surplus of crops.
Independent researcher and activist Ranjana Padhi says: "Since everyone had money, labourers were replaced by tractors and unemployment increased, while productivity steadily declined."
As production costs have risen, food prices have slumped.
Traditionally, the government buys grain from farmers and distributes it in the open market.
Sukhpal Singh, a senior economist at Punjab Agricultural University, feels farmers had to bear government prices that were too low and failed to take into account "risk factors like crop failure or soil maintenance".
Poor prices internationally restricted the government from a higher buying rate for farmers.
Another factor is the subsidies in place in areas such as Europe.
German non-governmental organisation Foodwatch says the European subsidies are responsible for large-scale unemployment and poverty among farmers in Africa, Asia and Latin America.
The issue is pending with the World Trade Organisation but talks on the issue have repeatedly failed.
Bernard D'Mello feels the worst is yet to come given the recent recession.
"Commodity prices are plummeting in the international market as a result of recession, which will depress the price in Indian markets as well and farmer suicides may increase in coming months," he says.
Punjab Agriculture Minister Sucha Singh Langah says the state government has increased farming subsidies to all categories in recent years.
But the Election Commission has put further projects on hold pending the polls.
Meanwhile the farmers' unions are co-ordinating a joint protest to highlight the plight of farmers.
Amarjit Singh will be one taking part. "We will stop everything in the state for two days," he says.
Mandip Kaur, a 29-year-old housewife from a farming family in southern Punjab, guards her husband round the clock.
"I fear he may commit suicide," she says in broken Hindi.
Almost every village in Punjab has witnessed a suicide in their once-prosperous farming families and it is a major issue in the general election.
Ms Kaur's 35-year-old husband, Lakhbir Singh, a small farmer with a two-acre land holding, is a strong and neatly dressed man.
He shows no sign of irritation or discomfort when we meet him in the village of Boparai Khurd in Barnala, about 500km (300 miles) north of Delhi.
Each year before the harvest, the small farmers of Punjab, who make up nearly 85% of the state's farming community, borrow from local rural moneylenders at exorbitant interest rates to meet production costs, including fertilisers and electricity for irrigation.
“ Commodity prices are plummeting in the international market... and farmer suicides may increase in coming months ”
"[Lakhbir] has a loan of more than 700,000 rupees ($15,000), which he cannot repay," says Ms Kaur.
Defaulting on payment increases the rates of interest and a farmer is publicly humiliated in the local panchayat (self-governing rural body) if he fails to pay up.
"His elder brother, my father, committed suicide more than a year ago, as his loan had accumulated up to $20,000," says 15-year-old Jasbir, who discovered her father's body.
"I do not think I can ever repay the whole amount," Lakhbir confesses.
The Bhartiya Kisan Union-Ekta, (BKU-United), one of the largest farmers' unions in Punjab, is urging its members not to vote in the election if they feel that none of the parties is addressing their needs.
'Major issue'
National Crime Records Bureau statistics say close to 200,000 farmers have committed suicide in India since 1997.
The Punjab government says the state produces nearly two-thirds of the grain in India.
But the state has faced many economic crises since the the mid-1990s.
No comprehensive official figures on farmer suicides in the area are available.
But a report commissioned by the government of Punjab this week estimated that there had been "close to 3,000 suicides" among farmers and farm labourers in just two of Punjab's 20 districts in recent years, agriculture ministry sources told the BBC.
The general secretary of BKU-United, Sukhdev Singh Khokri, says: "The findings of this report will snowball into a major electoral issue."
Another government report published in 2007 suggested that "about 12% of marginal and small farmers have left farming" over the past few years.
Among the reasons is the lack of access to credit, a facility denied by banks to farmers with no property.
"Bank loans to small farmers without collateral declined sharply as India introduced neo-liberal policies in the 1990s," says Bernard D'Mello, deputy editor of Economic and Political Weekly.
Farmers had to approach rural moneylenders who charge exorbitant rates.
Amarjit Singh, another small farmer from Barnala whose father committed suicide a few years back, says: "My father could not read or write, so he could not calculate the amount of loan he had incurred.
"Once it reached a staggering sum, he was publicly threatened by the moneylender and committed suicide.
"If I am asked to pay my father's debt, I will also have to commit suicide," says Amarjit, who has also taken on loans to meet rising production costs.
Surplus
The Punjab government's website proclaims that "India has gone from a food-deficit to a food-surplus country" largely because of the Green Revolution of Punjab.
In the 1960s, it revolutionised agricultural production by introducing high-yield varieties of seeds, chemical fertilisers, insecticides and machinery.
But the 2007 report criticises the revolution and its surplus of crops.
Independent researcher and activist Ranjana Padhi says: "Since everyone had money, labourers were replaced by tractors and unemployment increased, while productivity steadily declined."
As production costs have risen, food prices have slumped.
Traditionally, the government buys grain from farmers and distributes it in the open market.
Sukhpal Singh, a senior economist at Punjab Agricultural University, feels farmers had to bear government prices that were too low and failed to take into account "risk factors like crop failure or soil maintenance".
Poor prices internationally restricted the government from a higher buying rate for farmers.
Another factor is the subsidies in place in areas such as Europe.
German non-governmental organisation Foodwatch says the European subsidies are responsible for large-scale unemployment and poverty among farmers in Africa, Asia and Latin America.
The issue is pending with the World Trade Organisation but talks on the issue have repeatedly failed.
Bernard D'Mello feels the worst is yet to come given the recent recession.
"Commodity prices are plummeting in the international market as a result of recession, which will depress the price in Indian markets as well and farmer suicides may increase in coming months," he says.
Punjab Agriculture Minister Sucha Singh Langah says the state government has increased farming subsidies to all categories in recent years.
But the Election Commission has put further projects on hold pending the polls.
Meanwhile the farmers' unions are co-ordinating a joint protest to highlight the plight of farmers.
Amarjit Singh will be one taking part. "We will stop everything in the state for two days," he says.
Land Of Five Rivers In Water Crisis And Water Chaos
Farmer Suicides in Punjab
Farmer Suicides in Punjab
A Punjab Agricultural Univeristy report Farmer & Agricultural Labourers Suicides due to Indebtedness in the Punjab State -- a pilot project of Sangrur and Bathinda districts, submitted to the Punjab government a few days back has sirred a political storm.
The survey report says that 2,990 farmers had committed suicide in just two districts -- 1256 in Bathinda and 1634 in Sangrur district -- between 2000 and 2008. This report, more or less like a household census, is considered to be the first authentic survey documenting the spate of suicides among farmers and agricultural workers.
This report comes within a month of the Punjab government's decision to fix a price for farmer suicides -- Rs 2 lakh to the families of those farmers who have committed suicide in the past one year.
In Sangrur district, 738 farmers who took the fatal path to escape growing indebtedness, had an average outstanding debt of Rs 3.36 lakh per farmer. For another lot of 246 farmers who committed suicide for other reasons, the average outstanding amount standing against their name was Rs 79,935. As far as farm labourers are concerned, the average debt was Rs 70,036.
In Bathinda, the average outstanding due against farmers who could not sustain the growing indebtedness, was Rs 2.94 lakh. As many as 550 farmers belonged to this category. For another lot of 223 farmers who too committed suicide but for other reasons, the average outstanding debt was Rs 85,825. For the workers, the outstanding amount against their name was Rs 47,347 on an average. The report also provides a list of such households.
Meanwhile, another report in The Independent, London, says 1,500 farmers in Chattisgarh State have committed suicide. It blames crop failure and the falling water table to be responsible for the serial death dance. If this is true, I don't see why the Punjab farmers, who are endowed with assured irrigation, have to commit suicide. That means lack of irrigation cannot be the only reason. The PAU report blames growing indebtedness for the spate of suicides. Indebtedness comes from various reasons, and somehow I find we shirk from pointing to the real causes.
Reports about suicides in Vidharba belt in Maharashtra also ascribe it to lack of irrigation and distress sale of produce. While all this may be true, but I sometimes wonder why are we all reluctant to dig it deeper and find out the real causes that triggers indebtedness.
No comments:
Post a Comment